Sales Support 800-555-3353

The Do’s and Don’ts of Craigslist

Buy and Sell Jeeps and Jeep Parts on Craigslist

In This Article

Shopping on Craigslist is a lot like shopping at the thrift store – if the thrift store didn’t let you look at any real products until after you’d driven 20 miles to look at them. There are treasures there if you know what to look for, but you need to watch out for landmines and scam artists. Here is your map to navigating Craigslist auto ads like a pro – geared specifically to Jeep 4x4 owners and seekers.

Detecting a Craigslist Scam

If you’re trying to buy or sell your Jeep or some Jeep parts and accessories on Craigslist, there are some general rules you should follow. For instance, if a Craigslist ad …

Asks for personal financial information: walk away. Never give out your personal financial information to a Craigslist seller or buyer. Craigslist doesn’t certify its listings, so there is no filter for identity thieves and scammers except you. Banking information like your routing and account numbers, credit and debit card numbers, PayPal account information and social security number are a few examples of things you should never give to … well, just about anyone, but especially people you meet on Craigslist.

Only take cash. Whether you’re selling your Jeep or a gently used set of mud flaps on Craigslist, don’t accept any sort of payment other than cash. Anyone who wants to pay you through cashier’s check, money order or wire transfer is probably trying to scam you and if your bank cashes a fake, they’ll hold you responsible. Likewise …

Make all transactions in person. Be wary of anyone who asks you to ship items or pay through a wire transfer like Western Union or mailing a check – they’re probably scammers.

Meet in public. No matter what you’re buying or selling, set up the meeting in a public place. You don’t know who might be on the other end of the Internet and it’s best to be safe. If they can’t bring the item, meet them in a public space nearby, bring someone with you and then go to where the item is. On that note, you also need to …

Trust your gut! If you met a stranger in a Subway parking lot and they said “Hey, I’ve got a great set of Pro Comp wheels in my garage, want to come over and see them?” you’d probably say no. But that’s exactly what you’re doing when you shop on Craigslist, so if you meet the seller/buyer and your gut reaction is a bad one, walk away. It’s not worth it.

Of course, before you ever meet a buyer/seller from Craigslist, make sure to look closely at how they’ve been talking. Vague responses to your ad asking about “the item” and not your specific item, are red flags. The same is true if you’ve asked a question about an item and receive a vague answer.

For more information about avoiding scams, get it straight from the horse’s mouth on Craigslist:

What to Look for in a Used Jeep

If you’ve made it past the scam screen and are now looking at your potential new Jeep, here’s what you should keep an eye out for (on top of your usual used car check).

  1. The undercarriage. Get underneath the Jeep and check for scrapes, scratches and dents as well as signs of freshly painted or newly replaced parts. These are all indications that the Jeep has seen some off-roading action, which could be exactly what you’re looking for or precisely what you’re afraid of.
  2. Leaks. Look for spots and stains beneath the Jeep as well as visible damage to any tanks or hoses. The most common leaks are oil and coolant, but you also need to be on the lookout for transmission fluid, power steering, brake fluid, etc. If it’s a hot summer day and there’s what looks like water beneath the front driver’s side, that’s likely precisely what it is – condensation from the air conditioning unit.
  3. Rust spots. A little rust is to be expected with an older vehicle, but you want to check and make sure your future Jeep isn’t being eaten alive. Look for rust dust under the vehicle and around moving parts in the undercarriage as well as on the Jeep body.
  4. Modifications. If you’re looking for an off-roading vehicle, a Jeep that’s already been modified can save you a lot of cash, but make sure they’ve been properly installed and maintained. Be especially careful if the modifications are custom.
  5. The tires. Not only do you need to make sure the tire tread isn’t overly worn, you also need to look to make sure it's wearing evenly. Different tire wear patterns can indicate different issues with a Jeep, like poor maintenance or misalignment.

Whatever you find in your investigation of the Jeep (or any Jeep parts you may be buying), don’t be afraid to ask about it. It’s possible the stains in the driveway are from their spouse’s Subaru or the lift kit was installed by the previous owner.

The Do's and Don'ts of a Craigslist Automotive Ad

How to Write a Craigslist Car Ad

Do: Start off Right

Lead with a descriptive title: Year, make, model, color and an accurate price. Make people want to click on your ad.

Don’t: Try to Trick Buyers

Make sure your ad is in the right category, with honest and accurate info. It’s about the right people seeing your ad, not the most people.

Do: Take Pictures

2-3 well-lit exterior photos AND a couple of interiors of your Jeep (Not stock photos from the internet) will go a long way to selling your Jeep faster. Pro tip: Clean the Jeep first!

Don’t: Obscure Damage

If your Jeep has some dings, show them now. A potential buyer may change their mind if they’re annoyed about driving 45 minutes to find out your Jeep has damage.

Do: Give the Details

Post the year, make and model as well as the color, engine, mileage, transmission and 4-wheel-drive capabilities – at the very least.

Don’t: Copy and Paste Specs

A potential buyer is interested in your Jeep, don’t give them a robotic list of info pulled from the Jeep website.

Do: Include Mods

If you’ve modified your Jeep at all, make sure to include that information in the ad. It can help explain the price and insures your weekend warrior isn’t going to be used as a mall crawler.

Don’t: Bury the Lead

Information is great, but don’t write a 2,000 word essay and mention the brakes are shot at the end. Use bullet points, keep it organized and put the most important information first.

Do: Talk about the Title

Let them know up front what the situation with the title is. Are you the original owner, is the title clean, salvage, rebuilt, missing?

Don’t: Be Negative

Honesty is vital to a good ad, but make sure to stay positive. After all, you want them to buy your Jeep.



Don’t: Forget Spell Check

Check for misspellings (especially in the YMM) and if English isn’t your first language say so, so that they know why the language might be a bit choppy.

Do: Update Your Ad

Craigslist ads filter by date posted, so make sure to go in and update your ad once a week. If you change the price, make sure the title and body match.

Don’t: Post Multiple Ads

Few things are more annoying than seeing the same ad posted ten times on one page of Craigslist search results. Make one post and update it regularly to kick it to the top of the results and make it more visible.

Join our mailing list to receive information on new products, special events, discounts and more!